The records of the Carroll Pastoral charge include: Sacramental Register pertaining to Baptisms (1907-1968), Marriages (1908-1928, 1931-1967), and Burials (1907-1968); Communion Register (1907-1957); records of the Session (1899-1951); records of the Youth Group (1956-1957); records of the Young People's Union (1958-1959); and a Communion Roll (1952-1972).

The records of Carroll Presbyterian Church held at the conference archives include records of the congregation (1895-1923) and records of the Ladies Aid (1911-1919).

The records of Nesbitt United Church held at the conference archives include: records of the Board of Managers/Stewards/ Congregational Meetings (1900-1945); records of the Session (1956-1973); Communion Roll [1960]; financial records (1911-1934, 1954-1968); records of the Choir (1954-1965); records of the Union Sunday School (1910-1971); records of the Ladies Aid (1925-1937); records of the United Church Women (1961-1989); records of the Woman's Auxiliary (1946-1961); records of the Bethel Woman's Missionary Society (1949, 1958); records of the congregation (1955, 1992).