The records of the Killarney Methodist Church held at the conference archives include: Sacramental Registers, pertaining to Baptisms, Marriages, and Burials (1879-1921) records of the Quarterly Official Board (1912-1922); records of the Woman's Missionary Society (1918-1922); records of the choir (1914-1920); and records of the Sunday School (1906-1921).

The surviving records for Central United Church include: Sacramental Registers pertaining to Baptisms (1969-1981), Marriages (1969-1995), and Burials (1969-1996); Congregational Roll (1969); records of the Joint Official Board (1969); records of the Ministry (1974); records of the Official Board (1970-1978); records of the congregation, including reports and correspondence (1970), statistics reports (1970-1972, 1974-1980), and Annual reports (1969-1978); records of the United Church Women (U.C.W.), (1969-1984); records of the Pastoral Committee (1973-1974, 1979); marriage licenses and miscellaneous correspondence; records of the Ashford Study Club (1954-1961); and photographs (1935).

The records of Killarney United Church held at the conference archives include: Sacramental Registers pertaining to Baptisms (1927-1957, 1990-2004), Marriages (1927-1957, 1990-2004), and Burials (1927-1957, 1990-2004); Communion Rolls (1910-1943, 1975-1991); records of the Quarterly Official Board (1922-1938); records of the Board of Stewards (1956); records of the Council (1975-2003); records of the congregation (1957-2002); financial records (1912-1957); records of Management and Finance (1980-2000); records of the Worship Committee (1980-2003); records of the Women's Missionary Society (1948-1961); records of the United Church Women (1954-1999); records of the Pastoral Care Committee (1991-2002); records of the Building Committee (1997); records of the C.E. Building Committee (1968-1970); records of the Choir (1964-2001); records of the Young People's Union (1942-1952); records of the Christian Education Committee (1975-2003); records of the Fall Supper Committee (1997); records of the Ministry and Personnel Committee (1993-1997); records of the Change in Pastoral Relation Committee (1998); records of the Salary Investigation (1960); photographs (1943, 1984) and history (2000).

The surviving records of First Methodist Church includes: Sacramental Registers, pertaining to Baptisms (1883-1920), Marriages (1883-1906), and Burials (1884-1916); records of the Board of Trustees (1891-1913); records of the Young Men's Club (1902-1909); records of the Total Abstinence Society and Quarterly Official Board (1881-1887); records of the Sunday School, including a certificate (1923), and minutes (1890-1915); records of the Mission Circle (1907-1918); records of the Women's Missionary Society (W.M.S.) (1892-1897, 1917-1925).